• Home
  • About
    • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Services and Products
    • Educational Guide
    • Travel Agent

Disney in your Day

A blog all about Disney

  • Disney World planning
    • Theme parks
    • Resorts
  • Disney Subscription Boxes
  • Gift Guides
    • Disney Stocking Stuffers Guide
    • Disney Etsy Holiday Gift Guide
  • Disney at Home
    • Recipes
    • Crafts and DIY
You are here: Home / Disney Movies and TV / “For 10 years we’ve been rusting…”

“For 10 years we’ve been rusting…”

September 29, 2015 by Becky 18 Comments

for 10 years we've been rusting - Disney in your Day

One of the hot debates my friends and I had recently was during a re-watching of Beauty and the Beast (at my birthday party, in fact!).  And that has to do with the timeline of the whole movie.  How long has the Beast been a Beast?  During the song “Be Our Guest,” Lumiere has a line which states, “for 10 years we’ve been rusting,” which would mean they have been enchanted for 10 years.  However, we also know that the Beast has to find love before the last rose petal falls – by his 21st birthday.  So what does this mean?

for 10 years we've been rusting - Disney in your Day

The witch cursed a little kid

If we assume that they have been enchanted 10 years, and the Beast is currently 20 years old, that means that he was 10 when he was cursed.  Let’s let that sink in a moment – a witch cursed a 10 year old boy to this terrible fate, all because he wouldn’t let a stranger into his house.  Kinda hurts the whole idea of him being a terrible person who needed to learn a very important lesson if he was still a kid.

for 10 years we've been rusting - Disney in your Day

The Beast doesn’t age while he’s cursed

I like this idea, except that then there can be no concept of a 21st birthday.  If he was 20 when he was cursed, but then he doesn’t age, how can his 21st birthday ever be approaching? But if he was a child when he was cursed, why is there a portrait in the castle of the Beast as a human looking like he is his current age?  Was someone just really good at predicting his future appearance?

for 10 years we've been rusting - Disney in your Day

Lumiere likes to exaggerate

It could be as easy as this.  Maybe Lumiere just embellished on the truth a little bit to get some pity.  He seems like the type that might do that.  Perhaps it’s only been 2 or 3 years, but because they’ve been cursed that long it just feels like ten.

for 10 years we've been rusting - Disney in your Day

Chip was an infant when he was cursed

We see Chip turn back into a boy at the very end of the movie, and he’s definitely a young boy – he doesn’t even look like he could be 10, but let’s assume for the sake of argument that he is.  That means that when they were all enchanted he was less than a year old.  Only a baby, cursed to grow up as a teacup!

for 10 years we've been rusting - Disney in your Day

Someone made a mistake

This is perhaps the most likely, and unfortunate, situation.  Perhaps someone wasn’t thinking when they wrote the “10 years” line, or they didn’t pay too much attention to the timeline.  There is unfortunately two very contradictory elements to the movie: the fact that we are told 10 years have passed, in addition to the fact that there is a portrait of the Beast of a human somewhere in the ages of 18-20.  I can’t find any logical explanation to reconcile these things, as much as I would like to.

 

Do you have any explanations for this?

Filed Under: Disney Movies and TV Tagged With: Beauty and the Beast, Movie

Comments

  1. Lindsay AFM says

    September 29, 2015 at 9:13 pm

    I have never thought of this!! CRAZY!! Now I’ll be thinking about it all day 🙂

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:25 pm

      Haha sorry about that! 😉

      Reply
  2. Mark Brown says

    September 29, 2015 at 9:45 pm

    My friends at the Rotoscopers explained it best: TIME VORTEX!!!

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:25 pm

      It’s the only logical explanation!

      Reply
  3. Shann Eva says

    September 29, 2015 at 10:59 pm

    wow. I’m hoping my 5-year-old doesn’t catch that the next time he watches, or he will never leave me alone. Actually, he would probably come up with the answer, so maybe I should ask him 😉 It’s one of his favorite movies.

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:26 pm

      I’m sure it will be a 5 year old who comes up with the most logical and fitting explanation!

      Reply
  4. Megan Gonzalez @ The Busy Life says

    September 30, 2015 at 12:05 am

    I thought they were all frozen in time, meaning Chip was a little boy when he was cursed, just like he’s a little boy now. And if the Beast doesn’t fall in love before the last petal fell, he’d remain a beast forever. I thought they literally meant forever–that their little castle would be a place out of time. I don’t know about the birthday part…. Weird.

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:27 pm

      Right? I feel like I can explain parts of it, but then I think of something else that doesn’t quite fit. Some people here suggested that perhaps the servants are frozen in time from aging (because they’re objects) but the Beast still ages since he’s still in a living form. I guess that could work.

      Reply
  5. Rachel Wagner says

    September 30, 2015 at 12:27 am

    They did mess up. Plus the fact if all the characters in Be Our Guest are people then this castle had quite the staff. Also if he is prince where is his kingdom? He has no family? Who is ruling while he is a the beast?

    All that said, it doesn’t impact my enjoyment of the film.

    Reply
    • Kayleigh @ Sugar in My Texas T says

      September 30, 2015 at 4:13 am

      ^^^Yes!! All of those things!!! Damn Disney…

      Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:27 pm

      Oh I totally agree about the enjoyment of the film. It just made me laugh that when we watched this we had to pause it for a good 15 minutes to have this discussion. And that’s an excellent point about him not having a family. If he was a prince you’d think someone would notice when he disappeared!

      Reply
    • Arielle says

      January 20, 2023 at 9:57 pm

      It’s explained she made the villagers forget they ever existed. Families are reunited at the end. They are frozen in time. Only the rose ages. I used to think 100s of yrs passed when i was a kid but now im convinced lumiere doubled the time in his exaggeration and its been at most 5 since the servants families are still alive

      Reply
  6. Kayleigh @ Sugar in My Texas T says

    September 30, 2015 at 4:13 am

    And now this will drive me crazy for the rest of my life.

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:28 pm

      Sorry about that! 😉

      Reply
  7. Laura says

    September 30, 2015 at 5:24 pm

    I’ve always had two theories about this

    1) Time magically stopped in the castle (sleeping beauty style) during the enchantment. They know how many years its been but they aren’t aging

    2) Prince could have just been painted a bit more mature, artists did that kind of thing… If #2 is right though, frankly the Prince was just really aware of Stranger Danger, which is nothing to punish him for (in fact, that was the whole plot behind Red Riding Hood, GET YOUR STUFF STRAIGHT BROTHERS GRIMM!)

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:29 pm

      Those are fair points – I had a friend try to argue that they were more open about strangers and that sort of thing, but you make an excellent point that people were clearly aware of the dangers thanks to Little Red Riding Hood!

      Reply
  8. LisaLDN says

    October 1, 2015 at 1:00 am

    I think that time and aging has stopped when they are all transformed, and that the 21st birthday that is referred to is the day that his birthday *would have been*. So the rose follows the age of Beast as if he was still human, all though Beast (and all the others) stay the same age while they are transformed 🙂

    At least that’s what I started thinking now that I read your post and realised all of this! 🙂

    Reply
    • [email protected] says

      October 1, 2015 at 5:34 pm

      I’m thinking that’s probably what the intention was. But he would have to be very aware of how many days it was until his birthday when he was cursed! And that leaves me wondering exactly how old he was when the curse happened.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Me

Hi, I'm Becky!

I'm a huge Disney fan in my early 30's and always trying to find a way to put a little bit of Disney into everyday life. I live in Pennsylvania but travel to the theme parks several times a year - I'm an annual passholder at Disney World! In addition to Disney I love traveling, running, and theater.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
[popup_manager id="51"]

Archives

© 2023 · Disney In Your Day · Theme Design by Rakshi Creations